Questions & answers

Contents

  1. Who are you?
  2. Why this project?
  3. Where's the modern musical notation?
  4. Where can I find translations?
  5. Are you interested in collaborating on other projects related to the Cantigas de Santa Maria?
  6. Can I link to your site from my own website?
  7. Can I reference your work in an academic paper?
  8. Can I copy the contents of your site to WikiSource / my own website / my forthcoming book etc?
  9. The full texts of the Cantigas de Santa Maria have been on the web for ages (e.g. Portuguese WikiSource). Why can't I just use them?
  10. Some of your syllable breaks look weird. Why write quer' eu in CSM 1:1 and not quer' eu?
  11. Why doesn't X... or Y... or Z work in my browser?
  12. Can I play the Cantigas on my crumhorn?
Q.Who are you?

Andrew Casson playing citole with the group Gaïta

Andrew playing citole with the group Gaïta in their No Miracle Too Small concert of Cantigas de Santa Maria, Edinburgh, September 2009.

A.

The author of this site is Andrew Casson. I'm a professional software engineer, a performing musician specializing in the medieval repertoire, and a keen amateur philologist. So when I had both the idea and the opportunity to create this project around the Cantigas de Santa Maria, it pushed all my buttons, so to speak.

Languages, and their history, have fascinated me for as long as I can remember, probably going back to when I was five years old, and was taught to count to ten in French (in an appallingly bad accent) by one of the boys from the “big school” on the school bus. As a (rather long-term) consequence, I very nearly embarked on a Ph.D. in computer-assisted historical linguistics at the University of Sussex, when fate intervened and I ended up with a job at AIAI in the University of Edinburgh in late 1990.

My academic and commercial software engineering career from that point—which ended up in the role of Principal Engineer developing pre-press applications for a well-known Yellow Pages publisher—probably won't be of much interest to readers of this website. What Edinburgh really did for me was introduce me to medieval and renaissance music, initially via the route of historical re-enactment activities, but eventually in a more formal capacity as a member of Chris Elmes' group Gaïta. These days my personal performance repertoire covers a wide range of European music from the ninth to the sixteenth centuries, but at its core are the early instrumental dances (saltarelli, istampitte and estampies), French, Italian and English Renaissance dances from the 15th and 16th centuries and, of course, the 13th century Cantigas de Santa Maria.

Having left Edinburgh in 2010, I lived for four-and-a-half years in the green and cloudy north of Gran Canaria, where I made the most of the extended periods between paid software contracts to work full-time on this website. As of February 2015, I'm now back in the UK and based in the medieval Capital of the North, the beautiful historic city of York. Whatever my location, I've been very happy to be able to continue my collaboration with Chris Elmes in bringing the Cantigas de Santa Maria to a wider range of performers.

Q.Why this project?
A.

Two answers, one practical, one more philosophical. The first is simply that, when I started, no full edition of the Cantigas de Santa Maria existed that reconciled all of the text with all of the music into one consistent package. In particular, it is quite clear that Higinio Anglés, in what is still regarded by many as the standard (if not definitive) transcription of the music into modern notation, paid little or no regard to the lyrics beyond the first stanza of each cantiga; and it is equally true that Walter Mettmann, in editing the text according to purely poetic criteria, had no detectable interest in the music. So I saw a gap, and decided that it should be filled. To my knowledge, I am still the only person to have undertaken and finished this task (ongoing revisions notwithstanding!) and I am not aware of any similar projects that are anywhere near completion, either within academic institutions or conducted independently.

The second answer is that, whilst the Cantigas have nonetheless been the subject of much detailed and focused musicological, philological and paleographical study, it's very easy to lose track of the fact that they weren't written to be studied, but to be sung. So whilst I do naturally hope that some academic merit will be recognized in the work that I've done, it's far more important to me that the Cantigas be performed, recorded and enjoyed all the more as a result.

Q.Where's the modern musical notation?
A.

First of all, I would encourage all performers of medieval music to familiarize themselves with the original square notation. It's ‘the real McCoy’, and if you really understand it well, it will grant you a freedom of interpretation that simply cannot be matched by any translation into a modern score.

That said, I have nonetheless tried to ensure that the materials on this website are compatible with the edition of the Cantiga music produced by Chris Elmes and published by Gaïta Medieval Music. This four-volume set is probably the only full edition of the music available at the moment which is both reasonably priced and easily acquired, and you can order it from Gaïta's publications page.

Other complete editions of the Cantiga music exist, of course, but you'll be very lucky indeed to find them for sale in a bookshop, or even on the web: you'll probably have to go to a large academic library. The one you are most likely to come across is La música de las Cantigas de Santa María del Rey Alfonso El Sabio by Higinio Anglés (4 volumes, Barcelona 1943–1964), which was unchallenged for a long time as the standard reference for performers, partly on its own merit but also largely through the lack of any alternative. There is also the more recent but less well-known work Cantigas de Santa María: nueva transcripción integral de su música según la métrica latina by Roberto Pla (Madrid, 2001).

Partial transcriptions include:

La música de las Cantigas: Estudio sobre su origen y naturaleza con reproducciones fotográficas del texto y transcripción moderna
Julián Ribera y Tarragó
Real Academia Española, Madrid 1922.
Reprinted 1989. Translated and abridged as Music in Ancient Arabia and Spain, Stanford University Press, 1929.
—295 cantigas including all of [To] and a selection from [E]. The English translation reproduces a much smaller subset of just 43 of these. For the 29 from [To], the printed number is one more than the number actually assigned in the manuscript (because Ribera, for reasons best known to the illustrious Arabist himself, decided to call the Prologue number 1 and count from there), whilst the 14 from [E] are infuriatingly difficult to identify since the numbering is entirely Ribera's own (apparently continuing the sequence where the [To] transcriptions left off) and there are neither incipits nor underlaid lyrics.

Alfonso X el Sabio: Cantigas de Loor
Martin G. Cunningham
University College Dublin Press, Dublin, 2000.
—Just the 42 cantigas de loor, plus Prologue B and the Petiçon.

Interpretando la música medieval del siglo XIII: Las Cantigas de Santa María
Pedro López Elum
PUV Publicacions, Universitat de València, 2005.
Reprinted 2010.
—Just the cantigas from [To], but transcribed by reference to [E].

All three of these have been subject to harsh criticism, in particular Ribera by Anglés, Cunningham by David Wulstan¹ and López by Manuel Pedro Ferreira.² Without launching into my own reviews of these works, which I don't feel qualified to write anyway, I will just say that for performers (as opposed to academics), Cunningham's work is valuable and worth acquiring for alternative reference, but those of Ribera and López are not. Always remember though that there is no modern transcription of the Cantigas in existence that can be described as ‘definitive’, and there possibly never will be.

[1]  Reviews of Music in Music and Letters, Volume 83 (1), Oxford University Press, Feb 1st 2002.

[2]  A propósito de una nueva lectura de la música de las Cantigas de Santa María in Revista de Estudios Alfonsíes V, 2006–2007. (Article in Portuguese despite the Spanish title.)

Q. Where can I find translations?
A.

For a brief narrative summary in English of most of the Cantigas, you can now consult the Oxford CSM Database: just click on a cantiga in the Poems tab and you'll find the summary there, along with other useful information, although not the full original text. As of August 2013, however, there are no summaries of the Cantigas de Loor (numbers 10, 20, 30 and so on), presumably because these don't have stories as such.

The only complete translation into English that I know of is:

Songs of Holy Mary of Alfonso X, the Wise: A translation of the Cantigas de Santa Maria
Kathleen Kulp-Hill
Tempe, Arizona, 2000.
Reprinted August 2012.

This was out of print and very difficult to acquire at a sensible price for many years, but it was at last reissued in late 2012. See the publisher's page for ordering details (click on the ‘How to Purchase’ link). Note that the book is actually ‘print on demand’ and may take some time to be delivered after ordering—4½ months in my case, but you might be luckier.

In Spanish, the only edition I know of is:

Alfonso X, el sabio: Cantigas de Santa Maria
José Filgueira Valverde
Castalia, Madrid, 1985.

but this contains only the 200 or so Cantigas found in the [T] manuscript. I don't know for certain that this is out of print, but I strongly suspect so; please contact me if you know otherwise.

(Note, by the way, that neither of these two works includes transcriptions of the original Galician-Portuguese text or the music, so don't buy them with that expectation. Also, both are prose translations, so there's no chance of fitting them to the original music.)

However, anybody with a working knowledge of modern Portuguese, Galician or Spanish should be able to make reasonable sense of the language of the Cantigas, and this will improve over time, of course. I would just like to finish off this answer with a plea though: don't perform anything that you don't understand! Not only will knowing what you're singing about improve the delivery immeasurably, but it's always better to be in a position to judge the appropriateness of the content for your audience, even if you think they're not going to know any better. It's an unavoidable fact, for instance, that many of the Cantigas are sprinkled with the kind of casual anti-Semitic and anti-Islamic sentiment that was typical of the medieval period. If you're concerned about this, do your best to find translations of what you're planning to perform, and make sure that you at least put it into the appropriate historical context for your audience.

Q. Are you interested in collaborating on other projects related to the Cantigas de Santa Maria?
A.

It would depend on what the project involved, of course, but I would certainly be interested to know more, whether you're a performer, an academic, or indeed anybody else with a genuine interest in the Cantigas. Email me if you have a proposal.

Q.Can I link to your site from my own website?
A.Yes, please do. And tell your friends!
Q.Can I reference your work in an academic paper?
A.Yes, I would be delighted. See e.g. Cornell University Library for tips on the citation format for websites, but I suggest something like the following:
	Casson, Andrew D. "Cantigas de Santa Maria for Singers". Web, 21st June 2011.
	<http://www.cantigasdesantamaria.com/>

Substitute the date that you see in the page footer under ‘Database built’ when you access the site, as this is the safest determiner of the current site contents, which may change after you reference it. I would also appreciate it if you would drop me a note when you cite me. Thank you.

Q.Can I copy the contents of your site to WikiSource / my own website / my forthcoming book etc?
A.

Sorry, but no, you can't. You may not republish my work in any form whatsoever.

Basically, the principle here is credit where credit is due, which I hope nobody will take offence at. Although my initial work with the text built upon the exemplary work of Walter Mettmann, the project has so far occupied around two years of personal full-time effort—marking up and correcting lyric and music transcriptions, poring over manuscript facsimiles, proofreading, problem-solving, research, discussions with musical colleagues, web design, programming (over 35,000 lines of Perl and JavaScript source code as of July 2013), testing, and so on. I simply don't want copies of my work appearing without my name on them, neither do I want out-of-date versions of my work, or versions modified by somebody else, to appear with or without my name on them. The only way to avoid both is not to allow any copies to be made, and this is the only thing I ask in return for making this site available freely to all.

Q. The full texts of the Cantigas de Santa Maria have been on the web for ages (e.g. Portuguese WikiSource). Why can't I just use them?
A.

Even if these existing online transcriptions were of good quality, you'd still need to have a solid understanding of the medieval Galician-Portuguese language as used in the Cantigas, and you'd then need to duplicate all the work I have done in order to produce something that is ready to be performed in full. Unfortunately, however, all copies of these online texts that I have found so far—and there are quite a few around the web, though they clearly share a common origin—are of very poor quality, in fact so poor as to be unusable for performance. To begin with, they are riddled with dozens of OCR errors—such as "Sermor" for Sennor, "ab" for ali, "magãa" for maçãa, and absurdities such as the word "apelidoso" where the original word is apelido and the "-so" is actually Mettmann's line number 50. Much worse, though, is that fact that every single instance of the letters , ĩ, ũ and (that's e, i, u and y with tilde) has been dropped completely. That's a total of 2620 missing letters. Not only does this result in nonsense, but these four letters always represent a separate syllable, and their loss means that there is absolutely no chance of reconstructing the original metre and fitting the words correctly to the music. (A fine example of this is the mangled text "Ond' ha gran cuba cha devo pararon tal" from CSM 351:23, which should in fact read Ond' hũa gran cuba chẽa de vỹo pararon tal in Mettmann's original transcription.)

Q. Some of your syllable breaks look weird. Why write quer' eu in CSM 1:1 and not quer' eu?
A.

Simple question, rather technical answer: the r in the unelided form quero begins a syllable, and elision doesn't change that fact. The elided syllables must therefore be que and reu, not quer and eu. Whilst this makes no practical difference with the consonant r, it certainly does with n and s. Take CSM 31:31, where the word dano is elided:

sen dan' e sen ocajon

This contains syllables da and ne, so the n gets its normal syllable-initial pronunciation, resulting correctly in [da.ne]. Division as dan and e would make the n syllable-final, and imply pronunciation as [daŋ.e] which is definitely wrong. Similarly, in CSM 59:16:

e fremos' e de bon prez

it is important to keep the syllables mo and se, so that the s is syllable-initial and intervocalic, and therefore voiced, resulting in [fre.mo.ze]. If the syllables were broken as mos and e, this would imply [fre.mos.e], which is wrong.

Q. Why doesn't X... or Y... or Z work in my browser?
A.

Sorry about that too. Send me a description of the problem and I'll see what I can do. On Windows, I test this site as much as I can with the latest versions of Firefox, Chrome and Opera, as well as Internet Explorer 10, and IE9 as emulated by IE10. On Ubuntu, I test on Firefox only. That's all I have on the computers I currently own. When I can borrow a suitable mobile device, I also try out the site in Safari on iOS (and have actually fixed a number of things as a result). Finally, in my one and only concession to antiquity, I also try to ensure that the site looks more-or-less presentable in IE8 (as emulated by IE10) and IE7 (the real thing), although these lack certain important functionality, such as the HTML Canvas and the JavaScript Object.create and Object.getPrototypeOf methods which are required for viewing the music transcriptions.

Please understand though that this site is a labour of love, for which nobody pays me, and I'd much rather be working on interesting new functionality than compatibility tweaks for ancient browsers. So I'd just ask that you do whatever you can to ensure that you're using a recent version of a standards-compatible browser, and see if that solves your problem, before submitting any bug reports. If, on the other hand, you're stuck with IE6 on a computer you're unable to upgrade, then I'm afraid the best I can do is send my condolences.

Q. Can I play the Cantigas on my crumhorn? No Crumhorns
A. Definitely not; that would be silly. Crumhorns were, to quote an Early Musician friend of mine, “popular for about five minutes in the 16th century”. If you like musical anachronisms though, you might like to try playing CSM 159 on the electric guitar, which rocks.